5415 Stillwater Avenue

5415 Stillwater Avenue, Westerville, OH

Offered at $1,299,000 | Highland Lakes | Westerville City Schools

Property Overview

Simply exceptional describes this Parade of Homes custom design by Romanelli & Hughes, showcasing outstanding craftsmanship in the prestigious Highland Lakes golf community. Perfectly positioned on a spectacular wooded ravine lot with tranquil water views and a private water's edge deck, this remarkable residence offers the rare opportunity to enjoy peaceful views toward the Westerville Reservoir.

Offering approximately 7,204 finished square feet, including the finished lower level, the home blends timeless architecture, tasteful updates, and beautifully designed indoor and outdoor living spaces. The thoughtfully arranged floor plan features five bedrooms, four full bathrooms, one half bathroom, soaring ceilings, expansive windows, custom millwork, rich red oak hardwood flooring, and two gas log fireplaces.

The beautifully renovated kitchen serves as the heart of the home with custom cabinetry, a massive center island, high-end appliances, abundant workspace, and a walk-in pantry. The kitchen opens seamlessly to the casual eating area, hearth room, and dramatic two-story great room, where towering windows frame the wooded surroundings. A cozy library nook with built-in shelving provides an inviting place to read, work, or relax.

A grand foyer with a curved staircase creates an impressive first impression, while the formal dining room and executive-style study offer refined spaces for entertaining and working from home. A spacious first-floor laundry room with cabinetry, counter space, and utility sink adds everyday convenience.

All five bedrooms are located on the upper level. The spacious owner's suite features a tray ceiling, bay-window sitting area, custom walk-in closet, and a luxurious spa-inspired bathroom with designer finishes, dual vanities, soaking tub, and oversized tiled shower. An additional bedroom includes a private ensuite bathroom, while two bedrooms share an updated Jack-and-Jill bathroom. The versatile fifth bedroom may also serve as a bonus room, media room, hobby space, or additional home office.

The finished lower level provides extensive space for recreation and entertaining, including a large gathering area, custom wet bar, game and dining spaces, fitness room, full bathroom, built-in cabinetry, and abundant unfinished storage. Multiple flexible areas allow the lower level to accommodate a variety of recreational, work, and hobby uses.

Outdoor living is equally impressive. A screened porch with a vaulted wood ceiling overlooks the wooded setting, while the expansive paver patio features a pergola, built-in grilling area, mature landscaping, and multiple seating areas. Follow the landscaped grounds to the private water's edge deck, a peaceful place to unwind and enjoy the ravine and surrounding natural scenery.

Extensive improvements throughout the property enhance both beauty and function, including a remodeled kitchen, renovated bathrooms, newer roof, updated HVAC systems, water heater, restored windows, refinished hardwood flooring, updated landscaping, and lower-level carpet. A three-car side-load garage completes this exceptional Highland Lakes residence.

Virtual Tours

Interactive 3D Tour (Zillow)

Video Walkthrough (YouTube)

Coming Soon

Key Features

• 🛏 5 Bedrooms, All Located on the Upper Level
• 🛁 4 Full Bathrooms
• 🚿 1 Half Bathroom
• 📐 Approximately 7,204 Finished Sq Ft
• 🌳 Approximately 0.44-Acre Homesite
• 🏡 Custom Romanelli & Hughes Parade of Homes Design
• 🌲 Wooded Ravine Lot
• 🌊 Water and Reservoir Views
• 🪵 Private Water's Edge Deck
• 🔥 2 Gas Log Fireplaces
• 🪜 Grand Foyer with Curved Staircase
• ☀️ Two-Story Great Room with Expansive Windows
• 📚 Library Nook with Custom Built-Ins
• 🍳 Renovated Kitchen with Massive Center Island
• 🍽 High-End Appliances and Walk-In Pantry
• 🪑 Casual Eating Area and Hearth Room
• 🍷 Formal Dining Room
• 💻 Executive-Style Study
• 🧺 First-Floor Laundry Room
• 🛁 Renovated Spa-Inspired Owner's Bathroom
• 👗 Custom Owner's Walk-In Closet
• 🚿 Private Ensuite Bedroom
• 🛁 Updated Jack-and-Jill Bathroom
• 🎬 Flexible Fifth Bedroom / Bonus Room
• 🎱 Finished Lower-Level Recreation Areas
• 🍸 Custom Lower-Level Wet Bar
• 🏋️ Dedicated Fitness Room
• 📦 Generous Unfinished Storage
• 🌤 Screened Porch with Vaulted Wood Ceiling
• 🧱 Paver Patio with Pergola
• 🔥 Built-In Outdoor Grill
• 💧 Irrigation System
• 🚗 Attached 3-Car Side-Load Garage
• ⛳ Located in Highland Lakes

Recent Improvements

Interior Improvements

• 2026: New Fan on Radon System
• 2026: New Lower-Level Carpet
• 2025: Main Furnace Replaced
• 2025: Two Air-Conditioning Units Replaced
• 2025: Hot Water Heater Replaced
• 2024: Washer and Dryer
• 2023: Sump Pump with Battery Backup
• 2023: Ensuite Bathroom Remodeled
• 2023: Jack-and-Jill Bathroom Remodeled
• 2020: Red Oak Flooring Refinished with Three Coats of Polyurethane
• 2020: Complete Kitchen Remodel
• 2020: Range, Refrigerator, Dishwasher, and Microwave
• 2020: Automated Window Blinds in Kitchen, Dinette, and Owner's Bathroom
• 2020: Additional Laundry-Room Cabinetry
• 2019: Owner's Bathroom Remodeled
• 2012: Carpet Throughout
• Various: Interior Painting
• Various: Interior Trim Painted White

Exterior Improvements

• 2025: Roof with 50-Year Shingles
• 2025: Gutter Guards Replaced
• 2025: Six Windows Restored and Renovated
• 2025: Lower-Level Egress Window Replaced
• 2023: Patio Grill Refurbished
• 2016: Exterior Painted
• 2015: Landscape Lighting Added to the Front, Rear, and Patio Areas
• Various: Landscaping Replaced and Updated

Conveys With the Property

• Gas Range
• Dishwasher
• Microwave
• Refrigerator
• Washer
• Dryer
• Wet Bar Refrigerator
• Wet Bar Dishwasher
• Wet Bar Microwave
• Decorative Flower Pots Connected to the Existing Drip Irrigation System

Does Not Convey

Any excluded items shall be identified within the purchase contract.

Utilities & Services

• ⚡ AEP Electric: Approximately $271/month
• 🔥 Columbia Gas of Ohio: Approximately $204/month
• 💧 Del-Co Water: Approximately $108/month
• 🚿 Delaware County Regional Sewer: Approximately $119/quarter
• 🗑 Rumpke Trash and Recycling: Approximately $270/year
• 📅 Trash and Recycling Pickup: Friday
• 🛡 Security System Monitored by Guardian: Approximately $513/year
• 💧 Irrigation System Maintained by Rain One

Utility and service amounts vary by usage and were seller reported during ownership.

Taxes & Legal

• Annual Property Taxes (2025): $16,457
• Parcel Number: 317-324-02-004-000
• County: Delaware
• Township: Genoa
• School District: Westerville City Schools
• Lot Size: Approximately 0.44 Acres

HOA Information

• Community: Highland Lakes
• Managed By: Capital Property Solutions
• Annual HOA Fee: $450
• HOA Fee Includes: Common Area Maintenance

HOA information is subject to change. Buyers should independently verify fees, services, restrictions, and community information.

Additional Notes

• Traditional Two-Story Design
• Built in 1994
• Brick and Stucco Exterior
• Block Foundation
• Partial Basement with Egress Window
• Central Air Conditioning
• Forced-Air Gas Heating
• Central Vacuum System
• Security System
• Humidifier
• Public Water
• Public Sewer
• Invisible Fence Installed by a Previous Owner and Not Warranted
• Negotiable Possession

Title Services Provided By

First Ohio Title
413 N State Street
Westerville, OH 43082
Vicki Tucky
(614) 818-7639
vicki.tucky@firstohiotitle.com

Community & Location Highlights

• Located in the prestigious Highland Lakes community
• Community amenities include a clubhouse, swimming pool, and tennis courts
• Golf opportunities are available through the nearby Highland Lakes Golf & Country Club
• Convenient to Westerville parks, trails, shopping, restaurants, and community events
• Near Hoover Reservoir and additional Central Ohio outdoor recreation
• Convenient access to State Route 3, Polaris Parkway, I-270, and I-71
• Westerville City Schools
• Explore the Greenwell Group Highland Lakes Community Guide

Listing Snapshot

• 💲 List Price: $1,299,000
• 🏡 Property Type: Single Family Residence
• 🏗 Style: Traditional Two-Story
• 📅 Built: 1994
• 📐 Finished Sq Ft: Approximately 7,204
• 🌳 Lot Size: Approximately 0.44 Acres
• 🛏 Bedrooms: 5
• 🛁 Bathrooms: 4 Full | 1 Half
• 🚗 Attached 3-Car Side-Load Garage
• 🌲 Wooded Ravine Lot with Water Views
• 📍 Highland Lakes
• 🏢 Listed By: Kathy Greenwell & Luke Greenwell, Howard Hanna Real Estate Services

Disclosure

DISCLAIMER: All information is deemed accurate but not guaranteed. This page should not be referenced or initialed in offers. Items to be included with the property must be specifically stated in the purchase contract. HOA fees, community amenities, utility amounts, square footage, and property details should be independently verified. Video and/or audio surveillance may be in use on this property. Equal Housing Opportunity.

• Acres: 0.44
• garage: 3
• flooring: Hardwood, Carpet, Tile
• construction: Brick & Stucco
• roof: Architectural Shingle (2025)
• style: Traditional, Two-Story