512/514 S Otterbein Ave

512/514 S Otterbein Avenue, Westerville, OH 43081

Sold for $383,000 on December 2, 2024 | Lexington Farms | Westerville City Schools

Property Overview

Prime Location! This beautifully updated single-story duplex in the Lexington Farms area of Westerville offers a rare opportunity for both investors and owner-occupants. With major updates completed in 2024 and a central location near shopping, dining, public transportation, and freeway access, this is a truly turnkey property.

Unit 514 features 2 bedrooms, new luxury vinyl tile flooring, an updated bathroom, and a renovated kitchen with granite countertops, new stainless steel appliances, and a pantry. The spacious great room provides flexible living space and natural light.

Unit 512 offers 3 bedrooms, a fully updated kitchen with new cabinets, granite countertops, stainless steel appliances, and pantry, plus an updated full bath and large great room. Both units include partial basements with laundry hookups and generous storage space.

Exterior amenities include two tandem off-street parking spots in the rear, a shared storage shed, and updates to both HVAC systems. A fantastic duplex investment with modern features and strong rental potential in a desirable Westerville location.

Key Features

• 🏘️ Duplex with 2 Units (1x 2BR, 1x 3BR)
• 🛠️ Fully Updated in 2024
• 📐 1,732 Total Sq Ft
• 🔧 Each Unit Has Its Own Basement with Laundry Hookups
• 🚗 Tandem Off-Street Parking + Storage Shed
• 🌳 0.31 Acre Lot in Prime Location
• 🏫 Westerville City School District

Home Improvements & Included Items

• Interior Updates (2024): Walls and ceilings painted, LVT flooring, granite countertops and backsplashes, bathroom vanities, tub surrounds, kitchen sinks and faucets, toilets (both units); kitchen cabinets (Unit 512); water heater (Unit 514)
• Appliances (2024): Refrigerators and Electric Ranges (both units)
• Exterior: New A/C unit in Unit 512 (2024)
• Other: Furnaces in both units serviced and confirmed in good working order (August 2024, Waterworks)
• Included with Property: Refrigerators and Ranges in both units

Utilities

• Utility costs unknown – Seller has never lived in the property

Title Info

• Title Company: First Ohio Title
  Vicki Tucky – (614) 818-7639
  vicki.tucky@firstohiotitle.com

Tax & Legal

• Franklin County Parcel #: 080-003545
• 2023 Annual Taxes: $5,659.72
• School District: Westerville CSD
• Year Built: 1966 | Remodeled: 2024
• 0.31 Acres | Zoning: Duplex

More About the Community

• 📊 View Market Report
• 📍 Community Insights
• 🏡 Homes for Sale in Westerville

Snapshot

• 📅 Listed: October 30, 2024 | Closed: December 2, 2024
• 💲 List Price: $374,900 | Sale Price: $383,000
• ⏱️ Days on Market: 3
• 🏢 Represented by: Kathy Greenwell, Howard Hanna Real Estate Services

Disclosure

DISCLAIMER: All information is deemed accurate but not guaranteed. This page should not be referenced or initialed in offers. Items to be included must be explicitly stated in the contract.

• Sold: 12/02/24
• MLS Number: 224038652
• Acres: 0.31
• construction: 1966
• style: 1 story