5917 Rocky Rill Rd

5917 Rocky Rill Road, Columbus, OH 43235

Offered at $494,900 | Indian Hills Neighborhood | Columbus City Schools

Property Overview

Beautifully maintained and offered for the first time, this one-owner home is nestled in the highly sought-after Indian Hills community—featuring neighborhood amenities like a pool and tennis courts, and just minutes from Antrim Park, the Olentangy Trail, OH-315, and other key commuter routes.

Set on a picturesque 0.26-acre fenced lot with mature trees and lush landscaping, this traditional two-story offers 2,442 square feet above grade, a partial basement, and an oversized 2-car garage. Recent major updates include a new roof (2023) and HVAC system (2020), with additional exterior improvements like low-maintenance vinyl siding on the upper front elevation and some newer windows.

Inside, you’ll find original hardwood floors throughout the main living areas and all four upstairs bedrooms. The main level features a gracious entry, formal living and dining rooms, a spacious eat-in kitchen with abundant cabinetry, and a cozy family room with beamed ceiling and a gas/wood-burning fireplace. A convenient powder room and laundry room complete the first floor.

Upstairs, the home offers four generously sized bedrooms, including a large primary suite with en-suite bath, and a full hallway bath. The large, unfinished basement provides flexible potential for added living space, workshop, or storage.

The backyard includes an irrigation system, a patio, and plenty of space for entertaining, gardening, or play. This is a rare opportunity to own a well-kept home in a central, established neighborhood known for its convenience, charm, and community.

Virtual Tour

Key Features

• 🛏 4 Bedrooms
• 🛁 2 Full Baths + 1 Half Bath
• 📐 2,442 Sq Ft Above Grade + Partial Basement
• 🔥 Fireplace: Gas Log / Wood Burning
• 🏡 0.26 Acre Fenced Lot
• 🛠️ Built in 1968 | Updated Roof (2023), Windows, HVAC
• 🚗 2-Car Attached Garage with Opener
• 💧 Irrigation System Installed

Home Improvements

• 2023 – Roof & Sump Pump
• 2020 – Dishwasher, A/C & Furnace
• 2017 – Hot Water Heater, Garage Door Opener
• 2014 – Garage Door
• 2011 – Microwave
• 2007 – Refrigerator
• 2000 – Electric Range

Included with Property

• Dishwasher, Range, Microwave, Refrigerator
• 3 Garage Door Remotes
• Terra Cotta Tile in Entry
• Irrigation System
• Backflow Test Completed May 1, 2025

Utilities & Costs

• AEP Electric: ~$70/month
• Columbia Gas: Unknown
• Columbus City Water & Sewer: ~$172/quarter
• Trash & Recycle: Pickup Tuesday/Wednesday (seasonal)

HOA & Title Info

• HOA Fee: $300/year
• One-time Membership Fee: $500 (due at transfer)
• Link to HOA Information
• Title Company: First Ohio Title
  Vicki Tucky – (614) 818-7639
  vicki.tucky@firstohiotitle.com

Tax & Legal

• Franklin County Parcel #: 010-148185
• 2024 Taxes: $5,444
• Homestead Tax Credit: $439.82/year
• School District: Columbus CSD
• Condition: Trust | Built Prior to 1978: Yes

Thinking About Moving to Indian Hills?

Whether you’re buying your first home or relocating within Columbus, Indian Hills offers a unique blend of comfort, convenience, and lifestyle. This well-established neighborhood features tree-lined streets, community tennis courts and pool access, and easy connections to OH-315, Antrim Park, and the Olentangy Trail.

Part of the broader Northwest Columbus area, Indian Hills is valued for its mature homes, strong resale demand, and proximity to destinations like Worthington, Clintonville, and Dublin.

• 📊 Northwest Columbus Market Report – See pricing trends, inventory levels, and real-time data
• 📍 Indian Hills Community Guide – Learn more about schools, amenities, and the neighborhood lifestyle
• 🏡 Homes for Sale in Northwest Columbus – Explore real-time listings with live updates

📖 Want a closer look at what it's like to live here? Read our in-depth blog post about Indian Hills — featuring parks, trails, and the everyday conveniences residents love.

Disclosure

DISCLAIMER: All information is deemed accurate but not guaranteed. This page should not be referenced or initialed in offers. Items to be included must be explicitly stated in the contract.

• Acres: 0.26
• garage: 2
• construction: 1968
• style: 2 Story